On occasion, healthcare worker Lorna Grinnell-Moore has the receiver hung up abruptly. Frequently, she must hear to various far-fetched misinformation and, on one occasion, she remembers being verbally abused.
"There's always going to be individuals like those, who just don't want to hear, and it seems as though you haven't succeeded."
But this is all part of the routine duties for Lorna. Her role involves calling households whose children have missed out on measles, mumps and rubella (MMR) vaccinations to persuade them to receive the jab. Suboptimal immunization levels mean the disease has been able to spread in the city, mainly among children under 10 years old.
A Forward-Looking Approach
Lorna has prior experience - she was part of a team of public health employees that placed thirteen thousand calls in just three months after a spike in measles reports in late 2023 involved many pediatric cases. Just these phone calls led close to a thousand previously hesitant guardians and adolescents to accept the opportunity vaccination.
Across parts of London, which is grappling with a measles outbreak, officials are looking to cities such as Birmingham for approaches to manage the situation. Five dozen cases have been reported up to now, predominantly affecting young children, some of whom have been required inpatient care.
Leveraging Veteran Staff
Amidst the city's 2023 surge, some retired medical professionals were recalled from retirement, like they had been. On this occasion, however, as opposed to vaccinating people, they were tasked with convincing people to have them.
Their mission involved making repeated calls to guardians and individuals in the under-25 bracket to discuss what was stopping them receiving the immunization against a disease that can have grave complications - such as meningitis or sight loss and, in uncommon instances, death.
Presently, Lorna, the clinical lead for immunization services, and a team of nurses have been recruited to bash the phones again as infections are increasing again.
Navigating Difficult Conversations
It's not an easy task. It takes a certain kind of approach which combines listening closely and trying to understand the individual on the line.
"After I grasp their perspective, I can then respond to their concerns," states Lorna. "Sometimes they listen, and sometimes they say they are finished talking."
"This isn't a matter of becoming the bossy matron."
When individuals are willing to continue the conversation, Lorna is confident she can then ease their fears or worries about the vaccine and aid in reducing them.
Protocols and Support
The guideline is a maximum of three contacts. Another rule avoids leaving voicemails due to potential confusion. Staff members fluent in a variety of languages, like French, Italian, Arabic, or Urdu, can support the calling effort when English is not the caller's native tongue.
In addition to the call initiative, the collaborative outbreak team also runs an public awareness drive and works with local community groups.
Measurable Impact
The work across the city has had a noticeable influence. Throughout the last year, an extra 7,000 vaccinations were carried out – and the total number of jabs was 20 percent greater than the previous year.
Specifically, there had been lower vaccine uptake among specific communities, including Roma, east European, South Asian and black ethnic groups.
Language barriers were addressed by boosting the information available in various tongues, featuring scannable QR codes that lead to explanatory videos detailing the advantages, alongside the traditional public signage.
GP Practices Innovate
A number of primary care clinics have also started doing their own call-and-recall work. One of those is Hall Green Health, which has advanced the approach by providing doctor consultations to parents who are hesitant so they can discuss their concerns directly with a physician.
"In my view, society has become lax about just how serious measles is," says partner Dr Sonia Ashraf.
She says there are multiple factors that cause hesitancy. The inclusion of porcine gelatine in MMR is a frequent issue, but this is relatively easily resolved by offering the version of the jab that is gelatine-free.
Debunked studies from the 1990s linking the MMR vaccine to autism also gets brought up, while many families are anxious about the volume of recommended jabs offered to children. Before turning five, they will have been invited to get immunised six times.
"Many families ask why children need so many or believe their kids are robust enough such illnesses," continues Dr. Ashraf. "We dedicate time to presenting the facts with them – misinformation is widespread out there."
Resource Constraints and Prospects
The call-and-recall support has since been made available elsewhere. Yet, owing to financial constraints, it is something that can only be done in a constrained manner. Recently, vaccination levels dropped back to pre-2024 levels, leaving the city still well below the critical 95% mark needed for population-wide resistance.
Even with periodic rises in infection, there has been nowhere near the scale of cases that were seen two years ago, when reported infections topped half a thousand.
The head of vaccinations, says the proactive calling strategy "proves highly effective" but "not a silver bullet" and needs to be combined with other strategies. In an ideal scenario, he notes it would be implemented more broadly but more resources are necessary.
Existing monetary allocation for the initiative runs until the conclusion of the current fiscal period.
A National Picture
Birmingham is not the only area to adopt the strategy. Several other locations have tried similar things.
But shifting the dial nationally has been challenging. Currently, fewer than 85% of children have had two doses by the age of five.
"It poses a significant problem," explains a professor. "The causes of vaccine hesitancy are multifaceted and varied. A point commonly missed is ease of access. For